Togetter/min.tを安心してお使い頂くためのガイドラインを公開しました。

一般用語と学術用語のコンフリクト

確認できた範囲の英語コメント
4
K. Kobayashi @kobakaz_jp

Sexual harassment sustains biodiversity via producing negative density‐dependent population growth. Kobayashi, Journal of Ecology. besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.11… My latest work is published, showing evolution of sexual harassment controls the population growth rate according to density

2018-11-14 15:44:52
Journal of Ecology @JEcology

More on our latest paper from @KyotoU_News. Read more about @kobakaz_jp paper on sexual conflict and biodiversity. jecologyblog.com/2018/11/16/sex…

2018-11-16 21:32:51
Journal of Ecology @JEcology

Here is a link to the full paper: Sexual harassment sustains biodiversity via producing negative density‐dependent population growth goo.gl/qUHLYD pic.twitter.com/BvUQXkJWPN

2018-11-16 21:37:59
拡大
Journal of Ecology @JEcology

What factors sustain the diversity of life on our planet? Read our latest press release on the blog. jecologyblog.com/2018/11/16/sex…

2018-11-17 20:44:00
bob of booey @ColinJCarlson

so, @JEcology I can't imagine a good faith reading of the editorial process that happened here, but whatever happened, in no uncertain terms: this is a failure of peer review and journal management

2018-11-27 03:02:38
bob of booey @ColinJCarlson

here's the author weighing in. this is a bit iffy especially if something literally got lost in translation but...using sexual harassment as a term in evolutionary behavior research is a thing that's very 1990s and not, in any case, a good read of the room right now pic.twitter.com/fCyOQf8vm3

2018-11-27 03:12:42
拡大
bob of booey @ColinJCarlson

My quarrel, therefore, is 100% with the journal

2018-11-27 03:12:57
Jeremy, one hour earlier @JBYoder

This is an unbelievably poor choice of words. "Sexual conflict" is a term with established and specific meaning in evolutionary ecology. "Sexual harassment" is too — and they're not synonyms. twitter.com/JEcology/statu…

2018-11-27 03:09:57
Jeremy, one hour earlier @JBYoder

If you've got a PhD in evolutionary biology, you've got the wherewithal to choose terminology with some basic awareness of what words mean

2018-11-27 03:11:34
Jeremy, one hour earlier @JBYoder

Evolutionary biology has, historically, had a fairly substantial blind spot about gross sexual anthropomorphizing and the lesson to take from that is that we should be prepared to think about this stuff when we're talking about sex evolution-institute.org/article/coming…

2018-11-27 03:20:26
Colin @lowericon

@JEcology “Diversity through rape” was their first draft title, but they thought it might confuse and anger people.

2018-11-27 03:11:37
Joe Ballenger is getting COVID vaccinated ASAP @Stylopidae

Mmmmmm...this is a bad title, given the tendency of the Skeptic community to misapply biological science concepts to defend their misguided notions of how society works. I'm sure there's other ways to discuss sexual conflict in nature without framing it this way. twitter.com/JEcology/statu…

2018-11-27 03:15:07
Dr. Brian Lovett @lovettbr

@Stylopidae Not to mention the possibility of conflating "biodiversity" and "diversity".

2018-11-27 03:16:57
Joe Ballenger is getting COVID vaccinated ASAP @Stylopidae

@lovettbr Yeah, it's important to mention that the paper itself isn't discussing sexual harassment in the way that the #MeToo movement is discussing...but I'm sure that it's going to take all of 5 minutes for certain people in the Skeptic community to pretend that it is.

2018-11-27 03:19:18
James Waters @lovetheants

@hormiga @kobakaz_jp @BritishEcolSoc The title and terminology is revolting and offensive as is the whole premise of the paper. It’s like authors type an equation and reviewers/editors jump to publish. It’s just an imaginary model, no data or validation whatsoever?!

2018-11-27 03:21:08
Joe Ballenger is getting COVID vaccinated ASAP @Stylopidae

@lovettbr So, yeah. IDK. Like...I totally understand the phenomenon they're describing, and this sort of verbiage is used in the papers they cite. However, I read titles like this and think to myself 'Scientists need to consider how bad actors will interpret and use this research.'

2018-11-27 03:22:08
Terry McGlynn @hormiga

@lovetheants @kobakaz_jp @BritishEcolSoc in concept, I'm okay with a pure modeling paper (though it would be a lot better if it was validated with existing datasets), but yeah it does look like it's just a mathematical excuse to make light of a very serious concern in our discipline

2018-11-27 03:31:23
Dr Julie Blommaert 👩🏼‍🔬 @drjulie_b

Imagine thinking a paper title like this, in reference to plant evolution, is totally ok The authors should have chosen it, the reviewers should have objected, the editors should have told them to change it Why has this been published like this @JEcology? @DavidJohnGibson? twitter.com/JEcology/statu…

2018-11-27 03:36:39
Jeff Clements 🦪 @biolumiJEFFence

The chosen terminology in this paper is outstandingly immature, completely unnecessary, and, quite frankly, dangerous (pop media twists can be unforgiving). A contemporary failure from @JEcology and @BritishEcolSoc. How does this get through peer review with that title!? twitter.com/JEcology/statu…

2018-11-27 03:39:56
Joel McGlothlin @joelmcglothlin

@JBYoder Probably a translation issue. Still hard to believe this got past the editors!

2018-11-27 03:53:30
Jesse Alston @IntegratEcology

@hormiga @kobakaz_jp @BritishEcolSoc In many places in this paper, the author displays an incomplete grasp of English use and syntax—I think it’s reasonable to be generous in our assumptions about his motives. This is far more the fault of the reviewers, editors, and journal staff, IMO

2018-11-27 03:56:40
Jeremy, one hour earlier @JBYoder

@joelmcglothlin Editors, at least three reviewers, AND an author who is an adult with a doctorate working in an international field that uses English as a primary language.

2018-11-27 03:56:47
Jeremy, one hour earlier @JBYoder

@joelmcglothlin If *I* were submitting a paper about sexual anything in a language other than my first, I'd make damn sure I had the vocabulary right.

2018-11-27 03:57:00
残りを読む(79)

コメント

コメントがまだありません。感想を最初に伝えてみませんか?