電子書籍のbookmarkとannotationの標準化についてN.Y.で行われた議論 #bkmk11
-
- いいね！2
Hacks/Hackers NYC
@HacksHackersNYC
Brainstorm the future of online discussion w/@cshirky @amichel @ro_gupta & @HackHackersNYC on May 26! RSVP: http://j.mp/knm65s
2011-05-18 03:13:42
Dan Whaley
@dwhly
Kicking off... #NISO /@internetarchive conf on the future of E-Bookmarks and Annotation Standards at NYU #bkmk11
2011-05-26 23:15:14
ASMNW
@vaporbook
Beginning the NISO annotation and bookmarking discussion @nyu #bkmk11
2011-05-26 23:16:27
Kathleen Fitzpatrick
@kfitz
In a NISO/@internetarchive planning meeting on ebook bookmark and annotation standards at NYU today. #bkmk11
2011-05-26 23:16:56
Todd Carpenter tac_NISO at social.niso.org
@TAC_NISO
Goal of the #BKMK11 meeting is to explore the systems/standards/players/issues surrounding #ebook annotation and social reading #digbook11
2011-05-26 23:20:58
Marc Köhlbrugge
@marckohlbrugge
Remote participant of the NISO open annotation/bookmarking format discussion. #bkmk11
2011-05-26 23:29:16
Marc Köhlbrugge
@marckohlbrugge
Anyone from @IDPF at the #bkmk11 meeting? Wondering how NISO relates to them.
2011-05-26 23:34:28
Todd Carpenter tac_NISO at social.niso.org
@TAC_NISO
Rob Sanderson (Los Alamos) discussing the Open Annotation Collaboration work funded by Mellon #bkmk11
2011-05-26 23:37:40
Todd Carpenter tac_NISO at social.niso.org
@TAC_NISO
Sanderson: More information about Open Annotation Collaboration http://bit.ly/j1WnQa #bkmk11
2011-05-26 23:38:45
Todd Carpenter tac_NISO at social.niso.org
@TAC_NISO
Sanderson "Most annotations are about a part of a resource" & therefore uses constrained elements that describe segment of interest #BKMK11
2011-05-26 23:42:54
Todd Carpenter tac_NISO at social.niso.org
@TAC_NISO
Sanderson - Most difficult part of process has been definition of the scope of "Annotation" within the OAC project #BKMK11
2011-05-26 23:48:49
Todd Carpenter tac_NISO at social.niso.org
@TAC_NISO
Sanderson - Is an annotation just the link to the original thing, is it the version/snippet, what is sufficient? #BKMK11
2011-05-26 23:49:58
Todd Carpenter tac_NISO at social.niso.org
@TAC_NISO
Sanderson - Strong & growing community of 8 experiments to refine, improve model, and build implementations #BKMK11
2011-05-26 23:50:57
Marc Köhlbrugge
@marckohlbrugge
@dwhly Hypothes.is sounds interesting. What's the status? In development? #bkmk11
2011-05-26 23:51:55
Todd Carpenter tac_NISO at social.niso.org
@TAC_NISO
Will be gathering slide decks from any PPTs provided today & share publicly (if presenters are willing) along w/ notes aftr mtg #BKMK11
2011-05-27 00:05:06
Hadrien Gardeur
@Hadrien
We need new fragment identifiers for text, the rest is easy to solve #bkmk11
2011-05-27 00:28:17
Hadrien Gardeur
@Hadrien
Good fragment identifier for text is hard though, especially if a text can change over time #bkmk11
2011-05-27 00:29:13
Hadrien Gardeur
@Hadrien
Bookmarks, reading position, highlights, annotations are just additional metadata over a fragment identifier for text #bkmk11
2011-05-27 00:32:29
Hadrien Gardeur
@Hadrien
Once we have a fragment (or more than one), we can easily create data formats and protocols for interop #bkmk11
2011-05-27 00:34:27
Todd Carpenter tac_NISO at social.niso.org
@TAC_NISO
@Hadrien Not as simple, since there are needs for linking mechanisms, versioning, privacy, platform dependencies. ID is 1 element #bkmk11
2011-05-27 00:37:06
Hadrien Gardeur
@Hadrien
@TAC_NISO as for privacy, that's something that you need to deal with at a protocol level here, not at a data level #bkmk11
2011-05-27 00:39:18
Hadrien Gardeur
@Hadrien
@TAC_NISO tackling both protocol and data issues at the same time would be a mistake, need to work on those two separately #bkmk11
2011-05-27 00:40:03
Marc Köhlbrugge
@marckohlbrugge
@Hadrien @tac_niso Agreed. Probably more realistic to agree on the core issues related to interoperability first and work from there #bkmk11
2011-05-27 00:46:39