2015年11月28日

Josh Grisettiが「宝塚では結婚が許されていないのは公正か?」と問いかけた結果。

Plince of Broadwayで日本滞在中のJosh Grisettiの問いへのリプライとそれに関するツイートをまとめました。
14
Josh Grisetti @JoshGrisetti

Japanese fans: Q. "Takarazuka" girls are not allowed to get married. Do you think that's good/fair for these performers? 🙄😐🤔 #discuss

2015-11-27 18:55:03
Hitoe Nishino @hitoen9

@JoshGrisetti Not fair at all!No one can't stop lovin someone💞but same rule in other performer groups(not musical)in🇯🇵.Is it our culture?Hmm

2015-11-27 19:03:56
Josh Grisetti @JoshGrisetti

@hitoen9 I agree!! I find it appalling. Anti-freedom. Anti-love. In America, there would be public outcry and probably a major lawsuit. 😡👎🏼

2015-11-27 19:08:06
Hitoe Nishino @hitoen9

@JoshGrisetti yeah, it would turn out to be a big strike in US! But it also means Takarazuka has such devoted & passionate fans, I guess.

2015-11-27 19:11:50
Josh Grisetti @JoshGrisetti

@hitoen9 but the fans are mostly other women. Why would they want the performers not to fall in love and get married and families? 😱😰

2015-11-27 19:15:17
Hitoe Nishino @hitoen9

@JoshGrisetti TOTALLY AGREE.Guess..some fans know they're women but think them as their'imaginary lover'so don't want them love someone else

2015-11-27 19:22:29
Hitoe Nishino @hitoen9

@JoshGrisetti ok..if I went too far(already?),I would be socially dead😱but I adore u as a performer&want u to be HAPPY in ur life #loveisall

2015-11-27 19:30:37
Josh Grisetti @JoshGrisetti

@hitoen9 that's not healthy. For the fans or the performers. So I can't accept that as a valid reason to continue this archaic practice! 😤

2015-11-27 19:36:20
Hitoe Nishino @hitoen9

@JoshGrisetti I can't either!But I'm not a fan nor organizer of Takarazuka so hope u can hear from them.Guess no valid answer would come out

2015-11-27 19:44:30
Hitoe Nishino @hitoen9

外の人から見て変なものは変で、意見を受け止めるなり、違うなら理解させる。それくらいの熱意を持って、色んなものにもまれて、時間をかけて削られて残った芯が'文化'だと思う。日本人にしかわからない文化だというのは説明ではなく、自分を見つめ直して他人と向き合う作業の怠慢だと思う。

2015-11-27 20:07:32
Josh Grisetti @JoshGrisetti

@LovePhangel it's terrible!! The fans and the performers should stop this. #Takarazuka #CantStopLove Let's start a campaign!!

2015-11-27 19:09:50
@POTO_TRMRTK

@JoshGrisetti Agree I think Takarazuka culture is strict But people in Japan sometimes are strict with other performers when they're married

2015-11-27 19:17:10
AKI @tiktak_aki

@JoshGrisetti It isn't fair, but most pop girls' group r not even allowed to make boy friends. So Takarazuka rule didn't surprise me much!

2015-11-27 19:16:23
AKI @tiktak_aki

@JoshGrisetti Hard to explain! I would simply say it is culture!

2015-11-27 19:43:28
Waka @wacanoe

@JoshGrisetti In terms of Takarazuka 100years of history, it was originally established as training association for wedding, it's acceptable

2015-11-27 19:24:58
Josh Grisetti @JoshGrisetti

@wacanoe Tradition or history should not limit the rights of living, breathing and loving human beings! ❤️❤️❤️

2015-11-27 19:37:31
asuka @violet_str

@JoshGrisetti I disagree that.I think that it should be permitted a woman beyond the constant age(ex over35). be continued…

2015-11-27 19:12:15
ポンず。 @sayaramin

It's just not fair... I think marriage should be free. twitter.com/joshgrisetti/s…

2015-11-27 19:34:36
Josh Grisetti @JoshGrisetti

@sayaramin YES!! ❤️❤️❤️🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵

2015-11-27 19:38:06
KAHO @kahoinjapan

@JoshGrisetti that's not fair of course. I'm not fan of them so I can't say anything about it. But all we need is LOVE!

2015-11-27 19:55:58
KAHO @kahoinjapan

@JoshGrisetti your women..? You mean have so many girlfriends!? Haha

2015-11-27 19:58:12
Josh Grisetti @JoshGrisetti

@kaho19970325 no, I just admire them the most!! 😍😍😍😁

2015-11-27 20:40:53
残りを読む(176)

コメント

めいぷる@尻が脆弱 @maples_qma 2017年9月16日
一三翁の理念から言うと「結婚したら生活が家庭優先になる(宝塚優先にできなくなる)から」でも説明できそう
1
built in 2000 @machine55555 2019年1月2日
本人がそういった秩序のある世界に自分から来ているのだから、他者が勝手に成り代わって意見するのはお門違いやろな
6
nekosencho @Neko_Sencho 2019年1月2日
というか、不公正だと思うなら、それだけの訓練受けて才能も恐らくある人がお安く放出されてるのをゲットして何か興業でもやればよいのでは。「不当に」解雇された人も助かる、自分も儲かる、ついてたファンもうれしいと、損するところがどこもない気がするのだが
3
RIP豚@自立支援 @RIPton_buhi 2019年10月7日
この手の話で一番納得するのは明石家さんまの「お前らはファンと恋愛して結婚してる」というやつ。その愛情は一個人に対してではなく群衆に対して注がれるべき
1