Is Madoka a good anime?
-
bikasuishin
- 5012
- 1
- 1
- 1
-
- いいね！1
wahくん
@wah_s63
@bikasuishin @ptj_tsubasa that's just how is how my love for shinbou by getting mad at him for doing something below him
2011-03-24 01:53:59
wahくん
@wah_s63
@bikasuishin @ptj_tsubasa but i guess he's still not above doing jive jobs for chump change
2011-03-24 01:54:23
Alex Leavitt, PhD (they/them)
@alexleavitt
@wah__ That was an awesome response. What's the dominant "discourse" around Madoka anyway?
2011-03-24 01:58:02
wahくん
@wah_s63
@alexleavitt Mostly I WONDER WHAT THIS ALL MEANS, WOW THIS IS SO MYSTERIOUS~
2011-03-24 01:58:27
Petteri Uusitalo | ptjtsubasa@mastodon.social
@ptjtsubasa
@wah__ I respect your dedication.
2011-03-24 01:54:39
Petteri Uusitalo | ptjtsubasa@mastodon.social
@ptjtsubasa
@wah__ @bikasuishin Maybe the continuation will be more to your liking though! Side stories. Side characters. Slice-of-life. The usual jazz.
2011-03-24 02:01:40
wahくん
@wah_s63
@ptj_tsubasa The Shinbou I like does wacky comedies and... Bakemonogatari.
2011-03-24 03:03:05
Petteri Uusitalo | ptjtsubasa@mastodon.social
@ptjtsubasa
@wah__ Which some say is pretentious, overrated bullshit with tons of fanservice.
2011-03-24 03:04:03
wahくん
@wah_s63
@ptj_tsubasa I'm not opposed to slice of life, but it's not what I prefer.
2011-03-24 03:03:17
wahくん
@wah_s63
@ptj_tsubasa People can say anything they want. I'm just saying Madoka doesn't play to SHAFT's strengths.
2011-03-24 03:27:41
Petteri Uusitalo | ptjtsubasa@mastodon.social
@ptjtsubasa
@wah__ Interesting art direction and quirky budget management?
2011-03-24 03:29:02
wahくん
@wah_s63
@ptj_tsubasa No. I mean in attitude. The story is too normal for them.
2011-03-24 03:30:05
mt-i
@bikasuishin
@wah__ I think you're being disingenuous about Madoka. It's completely fine that you don't like it, but the way you dismiss it and refuse to
2011-03-24 03:03:41
mt-i
@bikasuishin
@wah__ acknowledge its qualities is exactly the sort of uncritical approach to the work that you accuse the show's lovers of. I mean, as
2011-03-24 03:06:28
mt-i
@bikasuishin
@wah__ little as I care about something like Cowboy Bebop, I don't go around claiming that its only quality is the music, and people only
2011-03-24 03:08:20
Petteri Uusitalo | ptjtsubasa@mastodon.social
@ptjtsubasa
@bikasuishin Wasn't it a minor flop in Japan, too?
2011-03-24 03:11:16
mt-i
@bikasuishin
@ptj_tsubasa I don't know actually, but it's sure particularly tailored to American tastes.
2011-03-24 03:14:12
Petteri Uusitalo | ptjtsubasa@mastodon.social
@ptjtsubasa
@bikasuishin I like to say "pandering" just because it annoys them.
2011-03-24 03:17:58
Tetho
@Tetho_mig
@ptj_tsubasa It wasn't. It was 2nd at the AGP in 98 & 99 and sold a few ten thousand of each DVD (not counting VHS and LD).
2011-03-24 04:57:05
Petteri Uusitalo | ptjtsubasa@mastodon.social
@ptjtsubasa
@Tetho_mig Huh. I stand corrected then.
2011-03-24 04:58:26
mt-i
@bikasuishin
Btw, this is the beginning of the Wikipedia article: "Cowboy Bebop is an influential, universally critically-acclaimed, and award-winning
2011-03-24 03:15:56
mt-i
@bikasuishin
1998 Japanese anime series". WP:NPOV lol. For some reason, no epithets like that on the article about, say, Hamlet.
2011-03-24 03:19:15
several cutscenes will play in sequence
@jpmeyer
@bikasuishin i love finding all the articles like that where nobody else gives a shit about the topic and therefore nobody invokes WP:NPOV
2011-03-24 03:30:45