ジュリアン・アサンジの主張をめぐる、「科学的ジャーナリズム」の不在とその萌芽(?) #WL_JP

ジュリアン・アサンジに対するスウェーデンでの容疑について、何一つ客観的事実として確立されていないにもかかわらず、「レイプ犯」だの「逆ギレ女」だの「ハニートラップ」だのという言葉で憶測ばかりが語られているだけでなく、保釈後にアサンジ自身が語った「司法当局のおかしなやり口」(BBC Newsnightインタビューなど参照)についても、アサンジの言葉は主流メディアで伝えられているけれども、事実として立証しようという動きが見られない――それにフラストレーションを覚えたベン・ゴールドエイカーさんと、ブロガーや記者のtweetsをまとめました。 続きを読む
3
Ben CatchYourCough Goldacre @bengoldacre

am i right in thinking that still, nobody has written a clear analysis of assange's legalteam's allegation of improper process by swedes &c?

2010-12-18 00:46:57
Ben CatchYourCough Goldacre @bengoldacre

seems to me there are two separate issues: (a) is he guilty? (b) is he being treated more harshly than someone comparable position?

2010-12-18 00:47:31
Ben CatchYourCough Goldacre @bengoldacre

essentially, i feel disappointed that no newspaper has factchecked the allegations of dodgy legal process he makes here http://bbc.in/hRIQV5

2010-12-18 00:49:00
Ben CatchYourCough Goldacre @bengoldacre

esp since there are 10,197 articles written here http://bit.ly/e582gS can someone, any paper, pls, treblecheck assanges/stephens claims? hmf

2010-12-18 00:50:57
Carl Gardner @carlgardner

@bengoldacre I've not written one thorough analysis piece, no. I have been trying to shed light on the various claims here and on my blog.

2010-12-18 00:51:25
Ben CatchYourCough Goldacre @bengoldacre

.@carlgardner that;s great, but i dont want "a bloke says in a tweet". i want a respected news organisation to fact check and write details.

2010-12-18 00:55:12
Carl Gardner @carlgardner

I agree! | RT @bengoldacre: @carlgardner great, but i dont want "a bloke says in a tweet" i want a respected news organisation to factcheck

2010-12-18 01:06:38
Ben CatchYourCough Goldacre @bengoldacre

also, speculating on whether he raped someone will go nowhere, while examining whether the process has been dubious is legit and achievable

2010-12-18 00:51:52
Carl Gardner @carlgardner

@bengoldacre Yes. Nothing that's happened so far has made me think the process here has been in any way unusual or dubious. #Assange

2010-12-18 00:54:19
Carl Gardner @carlgardner

@bengoldacre Harder to say about Sweden. But there are unreported facts like that Swedish *courts* okayed detaining him http://bit.ly/gWftmD

2010-12-18 00:58:16
Carl Gardner @carlgardner

@bengoldacre Not widely reported here, I should say.

2010-12-18 00:58:36
n o f r i l l s /共訳書『アメリカ侵略全史』作品社 @nofrills

メモ:なるほど、こんな話が出ているのか。12月2日のAP通信の記事。 http://bit.ly/hoRA1b スウェーデン検察当局は、正式な起訴手続はしていないが、下級裁判所がアサンジの身柄をスウェーデンに移送できるとの法的判断を示している、と。/via 法律家

2010-12-18 13:55:59
Carl Gardner @carlgardner

I agree. It's wrong for people to prejudge this. | RT @bengoldacre: speculating whether #Assange raped someone will go nowhere

2010-12-18 01:00:22
Ben CatchYourCough Goldacre @bengoldacre

@Sukisioux honestly, i dont think any discussion on the internet of whether someone raped someone is gooing to go anywhere good, either side

2010-12-18 00:52:30
Ben CatchYourCough Goldacre @bengoldacre

sorry to go on about this, but no discussion on t'internet about whether someone raped someone, or not, can go anywhere good, on either side

2010-12-18 00:54:13
Padraig Reidy @mePadraigReidy

@bengoldacre have an interview with head of Swedish Bar Association coming up on @indoncensorship this afternoon

2010-12-18 00:53:44
Ben CatchYourCough Goldacre @bengoldacre

@mePadraigReidy again, that's ok, but i want a respected news organisation to fact check this and give me the details. it's been long nuf.

2010-12-18 00:55:43
Ben CatchYourCough Goldacre @bengoldacre

please, i will go on dirty protest soon. i want a respected news organisation to fact check assanges/stephens allegtions, and publish detail

2010-12-18 00:56:41
Ben CatchYourCough Goldacre @bengoldacre

@latentexistence i've got other things to do. i write a science column for a hobby. i want to pay some fricking journalists to do this job

2010-12-18 01:03:37
Ben CatchYourCough Goldacre @bengoldacre

@carlgardner is it really true that nobody has done this job yet? i think thst's a frickin scandal for international journalism

2010-12-18 01:04:21
Carl Gardner @carlgardner

@bengoldacre I don't think they have, no. It seems not to have occurred the media that #Assange is doing a great public advocacy job ...

2010-12-18 01:09:26
Carl Gardner @carlgardner

@bengoldacre ... but that there's another, less reported side and perhaps another way of looking at some of his claims #Assange

2010-12-18 01:10:05
残りを読む(101)

コメント

n o f r i l l s /共訳書『アメリカ侵略全史』作品社 @nofrills 2010年12月18日
しかしこの人たちは、なんで140字でこんなに理路整然と語れて、こんなにタイピングが早くて、そしてなんでこんな夜中にこんな胃もたれするような話ができるのだろう(英国は、タイムスタンプの時間-9時間)……しかも、別の話題と同時進行だったり(特にサニーは超人)。さらに18日はベンもサニーもUK Uncutのデモ。
0